What we found, and what it changed.
Three recent projects, told in full: where the client stood, what the data showed, what we did or recommended, and what it means if you are in a similar spot.
We do not publish client names. Industries, markets and numbers are real. Competitors are described by role, not by name.
Category study, three brands
Situation
A yarn and craft-supplies brand competing in the US market, the challenger in its category there, wanted to know where it stood against two direct competitors, in Google and in AI answers.
In July 2026 we ran a category study: three brands, 15 commercial queries, the same list for every brand. For each query we recorded search volume, cost per click and whether Google showed an AI Overview. Then we asked ChatGPT, with web search on, the questions a buyer would ask, and counted which brands it named.
What we found
- 01Google and ChatGPT disagreed about who was winning
The challenger held the most buyer queries in Google's top 3: 3 of 15, against 2 for the market leader and none for the third brand. In ChatGPT it was named in 0 of 10 buyer prompts. The market leader was named in 6, usually first. The third brand in 2.
- 02AI was already answering most of the category
9 of the 15 queries showed an AI Overview, covering 59% of the category's search volume. On those queries a ranking no longer guarantees the click. You have to be one of the sources the answer cites.
- 03Traffic was not the same as ownership
The market leader took 68% of the tracked brands' organic traffic, about 135k visits a month, yet ranked top 3 for only 2 of the 15 buying queries. The third brand had a Domain Rating of 70 and 38k visits a month, and owned none.
- 04Most of the site did no work
Of the challenger's 10,455 indexable pages, 471 ranked for anything. 96% was dead weight, the highest in the set.
What we recommended
We put the AI citation gap first. It was the most urgent gap and the cheapest to close: the rankings were already there, the citations were not.
Three moves: rebuild the pages that already rank top 3 so they answer the question directly, with definitions, comparison tables and explicit Q&A; add structured data that names the brand and its products as entities; and track citation share weekly across the same buyer prompts, so a decline shows up before it reaches traffic.
Alongside that, prune or consolidate the pages that earn nothing, and fight the leader in Google and in AI answers at the same time. On these queries the AI answers were reinforcing the existing winners, so picking one channel would not be enough.
Ranking well in Google does not mean the models recommend you. If most of your category already sits under AI Overviews, check who ChatGPT names before you buy another link. The gap is often wider than the rankings suggest, and cheaper to close.
Foundation audit
Situation
An international property platform had moved a whole section of the site to a new structure. The move went live without a redirect map. From the inside, a move like that rarely looks broken: the new pages work and the navigation points to them.
Google still had the old addresses. We ran a foundation audit to see what the move had cost and what was holding the site back underneath it.
What we found
- 01The old addresses led nowhere
302 of the 322 retired URLs returned a hard 404. Everything those pages had earned in search, their rankings and their links, now pointed at an error page.
- 02Search demand was still arriving at dead pages
Those dead URLs were still collecting 5,716 impressions a quarter. Searchers were being shown pages that no longer existed.
- 03The best content was cut off from the site
16 long-form guides had zero internal links. No page on the site pointed to them, so neither visitors nor crawlers had a path in.
What we did
We rebuilt the redirect map, matching each retired URL to the page that now does its job, so the old addresses pass their value on instead of ending in an error.
We rebuilt the internal link graph so the 16 orphaned guides are linked from the pages that cover their topics, and the site's authority reaches them.
A migration is not done when the new pages go live. It is done when every old address that Google knows has somewhere to go. If you have moved a section, check the retired URLs and the pages nothing links to. That loss does not show up in a design review.
Competitive study, five platforms
Situation
A platform selling video streaming to businesses in the US market had one of the strongest domains there. The question was why it held so few of the queries that bring in customers.
We compared it with four competing platforms on the same list of commercial queries, then looked at how authority moved through the client's own site.
What we found
- 01Strong domain, weak results
With a Domain Rating of 78, the client had the second-strongest domain of the five. It held the top 3 for just 1 of 10 commercial queries.
- 02The money pages were buried
The pages that sell sat five clicks from the homepage. That far down, both crawlers and buyers rarely get there.
- 03Internal links went to the wrong pages
The commercial pages received a fraction of the internal links that legal and support pages did. The site was sending its authority to pages that do not sell.
What we recommended
We recommended moving the commercial pages up the structure, closer to the homepage, and rerouting internal links so authority flows to the pages that sell instead of pooling on legal and support pages.
The point was not to earn more authority. The authority was there. It needed to be pointed at the right pages.
A high Domain Rating does not win queries on its own. If a strong site still misses the queries that sell, look at where your internal links go and how many clicks your money pages sit from the homepage before you pay for more links.
Want the same read on your market?
Book a 30-minute consultation about where buyers find you, who they find instead, and what we would fix first. If it helps, we can take a short look at your site and two competitors before the call. Or start with the Acquisition Intelligence Report.